Just had a curious thought watching some old footage; if TLFR hadn't have been released but songs like Bed of Roses, Its My Life etc were played in its style as live alternates, would you still dislike them?

For example, Jovi pulled out an excellent piano ballad version of Die For You a while back which I personally love. Would you still give some of the TLFR versions flack if they were only used live? Would you appreciate some of them more?