Quote:
|
Originally Posted by The Walrus
It does amuse me the way that everyone on this board is so adamant that "It's all about the music", until this topic comes up ....
|
Anyone who claims it is "all about the music" is talking shit. If it is solely musical accomplishment you were looking for, you would only be interested in, at most, a handful of rock and roll bands.
Rock music has always been as much about excitement and attitude has it has high quality song writing and musicianship. Can you imagine the Rolling Stones would have achieved success if they had all looked like Hugh, or Guns n Roses, or even Bon Jovi for that matter?
If it were All About the Music, Jon would be an offstage songwriter, or maybe a ryhthym guitarist and Richie would be upfront singing the ass out of those songs.
Fortunately, it is not. We realise that live, being entertained is just as important as being impressed musically and that Jon and his amazingly big balls (he gets away with so, so much overthe top nonsense that would make anyone else look completely ridiculous!) put on an absolutely spectacular show.
Alec, for what it's worth had the attitude that let you know you were watching a rock & roll band where anything could happen and that people lived for the scene.
Hugh is obviously a talented bassist, but I just wish his flexibility was used a bit more to give the band a spontenaity they couldn't have had with a lesser player.
Performance wise, though, he could fit right in with Nickelback. Who knows, if he maybe showed a bit more energy Jon might even let his picture appear on a t-shirt or album cover!