We already made Jon gay, let Richie be the axe murderer- LOL! Actually, I feel Winona is obviously sick as she wasn't shoplifting for lack of funds so I do feel sympathy and hope she gets help. I think a crime like murder would turn me against the guys but anything related to a possible mental illness or emotional problem would probably generate sympathy. For example if Jon or Richie turned up looking like that Nick Nolte picture wandering around and on some kind of drug I would feel very badly for them. But let one of them pull an OJ (oh, that's right he was found innocent) and they would lose me.