[Alphavictim]

Originally Posted by Jovi98

Hi ,

I can't realize why the tracklist of the box set of the 2004 it was slightly changed at the last minute before the release, is a strange thing....
One song of those is One to Say Goodbye but probably there were others that was eliminated from the box set at the last....
Maybe the cause it was the record company....... but for eliminate also only one song the mounth before from one album there must be a justifiation.

What is your thought about the story?

Do we know how many songs were cut, and more song titles?

[Jovi98]

Originally Posted by Alphavictim

Do we know how many songs were cut, and more song titles?

We know that 1 or 2 songs have been eliminated from the Box set at last minute…… : 1) One to Say Goodbye and maybe 2) Rumble In The House,but here there are guys that know more things about the Box set than me

[Captain_jovi]

Originally Posted by Alphavictim

Do we know how many songs were cut, and more song titles?

Apart from what One to say....anything else is speculation.

[Jovi98]

Hi , Satellite is an outtake from the Crush era And Who would you die for is an outtake from The Circle right?

[Alphavictim]

Who Would You Die For is a weird one. Soundwise, it seems like it was written after What About Now; but the vocal is EXTREMELY strong. Not only for that era, but would be even for The Circle.

Satelite is from the 90s I believe? So pre-Crush but among the batch of songs written for it I guess.

[Jovi98]

In Who Would You Die For Jon's tonality and the sound reminds me The Circle, but I'm not sure at 100% ....and Satellite i've always thought that was from 1998/99 or (2001 because the title and the lyric of the song reminds me some songs of the Bounce album about the theme of the distance....kind "The Distance " "Postcards From The Wasteland" etc....)

[bonjovi90]

I've always connected Satellite to Bounce, probably because of the satellite dishes on the album etc.

Who Would You Die For never has been clarified, but I can imagine it being from the Circle sessions because, even with all studio trickery, I can't imagine Jon pulling that off in 2015.
I'm with Alphavictim in that it sounds from a different "era", but then again "A Teardrop To The Sea" (clearly from 2015) doesn't fit in with the other standard songs from WAN to THINFS either.

[Jovi98]

Originally Posted by bonjovi90

I've always connected Satellite to Bounce, probably because of the satellite dishes on the album etc.

Who Would You Die For never has been clarified, but I can imagine it being from the Circle sessions because, even with all studio trickery, I can't imagine Jon pulling that off in 2015.
I'm with Alphavictim in that it sounds from a different "era", but then again "A Teardrop To The Sea" (clearly from 2015) doesn't fit in with the other standard songs from WAN to THINFS either.

yeah Satellite is also in theme with the satellite dishes on the cover of the album!

[Jovi98]

In this Italian link there are some titles of outtakes and alternative titles from The Circle.....
https://www.bonjovimusic.it/album/the-circle-16
1) "Don't Walk"
2)"Escape From The City"
3) "The Circle"
4) "This Ain't Love"
5) "This Is Our House"
6) "Time Machine"

[jazzsta]

Satellite sounds clearly 90s and not 2001-2002 to me.

Who would you die for sounds a lot Burning Bridges Ok it could have been Circle but I do believe studio trickery can make Jon sound like that (Devil's In The Temple is another example) and I have the feeling that the timbre of Jon's voice is 2014-2015 and not 2009.