I think doing this album by album is a lot quicker to read, as it basically boils down to "are my favorites there?".

@Kathleen: Crush was released in 2000 - this thread is about the last 10 years, so... 2005 - 2015? Yeah, I know.

For me:
HAND:
Title track
I Am
Last Man Standing
Dirty Little Secret

Lost Highway:
Any Other Day

The Circle:
Learn To Love
Bullet
Happy Now

WAN:
I'm With You
Room At The End Of The World

BB:
Who Would You Die For