My votes:

Best Studio Album
1. Crush
2. HAND
3. The Circle
4. Bounce
5. Lost Highway

Best Compilation Album
1. Boxset
2. One Wild Night
3. This Left Feels Right

Best Overall Song
1. Last Man Standing
2. Undivided
3. Two Story Town
4. Any Other Day
5. The Distance
6. One Wild Night
7. Novocaine
8. Have A Nice Day
9. It's My Life
10. Make A Memory
11. Brokenpromiseland
12. Thank You For Loving Me
13. Superman Tonight
14. Whole Lot Of Leaving
15. Just Older
16. Hook Me Up
18. Love's The Only Rule
19. Right Side Of Wrong
20. Say It Isn't So

Best B-Side / Demos
1. Nothing
2. Dirty Little Secret
3. Walk Like A Man
4. Stay
5. Satellite
6. Neurotica
7. Maybe Someday
8. Temptation
9. Lonely
10. Put The Boy Back In Cowboy

Best DVD
1. The Crush Tour
2. TLFR
3. Lost Highway

(I havent seen MSG yet)

Best Music Video
1. It's My Life
2. Say It Isn't So
3. Have A Nice Day
4. Misunderstood
5. Who Says You Can't Go Home (Dog version)

Best Tour
1. Lost Highway
2. Have A Nice Day
3. Bounce

Best Individual Show
1. Twickenham 2008 Night 1
2. Milton Keynes 2006 Night 2
3. Twickenham 2008 Night 2
4. Milton Keynes 2006 Night 1
5. Hyde Park 2003

(Neither the Best Tour nor the Best Show have to be one you actually experienced live, I've just chosen to do it that way)