Aloha !
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheseDaysEra
... Now, do you hear that in the albums ? Can you hear that in Burning Bridges? Some of the vocals in the album may be years old but others certainly aren't. The answer is NO, you can't. He sounds powerful and 'out there'.
Cheers
|
I beg to differ. I think that ever since Have A Nice Day, but especially on The Circle, you actually can hear how he just wasn't able to reach the stuff and studio trickery was done. Now, on Burning Bridges, the chorusses just don't sound natural.
I'm sure most people aren't able to hear it, but if you're a singer or know how singing and pronouncing stuff works, you are able to hear how a lot of stuff just has never been sung the way it sounds on the albums.
Apart from that, there's the poor way of copying and pasting on recent albums where Jon's not breathing in and out for a good minute or so. Jon's not going full throttle on the albums, but is putting on a fake rasp, which then seems to be pitched to the right volume, tempo and key.
Apart from that, many of his vocals are double tracked to give it a fuller effect. A trained ear can hear the differences, but the average Joe can't. The verses of It's My Life have him doing backing vocals for the entire song, a thing which is obvious when listening to the song a capella. Yet I'm sure this is news to a lot of people, but it's the reason why the song has never sound as good live as it does in the studio.
Now double tracking is something that's common in (pop) music exactly because most pop artists were good in the studio, but not so much live. Jon's voice used to be good enough that not a whole lot of that was needed, and he was pretty much always able to duplicate some of the studio vocals live. Nowadays, not so much. He hasn't sound good live in a few years because apart from his upper range being gone, his tone is gone as well. And that's something they are able to create in a studio.
An example: In the chorus of Saturday Night Gave Me Sunday Morning, the words "Saturday Night" seem to come from a different take in which he's using a different technique to reach that key. He can't change technique fast enough to pronounce the rest of the sentence the same way, so hence a different take is needed. And that's when Jon stopped sounding "out there" to me. Jon's no longer singing in the studio, but just pronouncing the words in the right key with an odd accent or technique that make it sound like rasp. It's not natural, and it's why it can't be replicated live.
Quote:
|
Not true. There is only so much you can to a vocal using editing and pitch correction. You can't really change its tone (without making it sound like an effect).
|
Which is why Jon's voice nowadays does sound like an effect. The difference between him in the studio and him singing live is night and day. Anytime I hear a new studio take, I instantly hear all the tricks they've done to his vocals to make him sound good. It's why Lost Highway, despite the poor quality of the album itself, was a breath of fresh air. His vocals were recorded in a much more natural way. A live rendition of Whole Lot Of Leavin' still sounds close to the studio version, yet anything recorded after sounds different.
Salaam Aleikum,
Sebastiaan