Aloha !
Your story reminds me of Sad Song Night. Especially this part :
Well I never went back to the Spanish town
Hung up my dancing shows
And the world kept on spinning round and round
I think of her when they play that song
Sometimes I even sing along...
Yes I know she was Mexican, but it's a nice story. I don't like Hush too much, but when looking at your point of view I understand your need of hearing it live someday. I don't think it would work when played live though, but I do know what you mean.
Salaam Aleikum,
Sebastiaan