Everyday, on the whole, is a much better song than It's My Life, in my opinion. Furthermore, it's a better song live. I think the vocals on It's My Life when played live are just pathetic. Jon's voice is flat when he sings it. On the other hand, Everyday doesn't really have any difficult notes to hit, henceforth, Jon has no problem singing it.

Don't get me wrong, It's My Life is a great song, but it sounds pretty bad live.