I dunno.... the only standards that people are comparing Jon to are his own past performances, so nobody can claim that we are being overly critical. There's no doubt he is the weak link in the band when playing live.

Having said that Jim has a point, when you are at the concert itself you tend to not scrutinise as closely. I think most people were praising the 2008 MSG shows but once the DVD came out people were not happy with the vocals.