I love Jon's vocals, he inspired me to become the best singer I can become many years ago, and I still work at it every single day. My favourite album as far as singing is conserned is Keep the faith.
His voice has lost power yes, heīs still good though.
Iīve studied singing (particularly rock singing) and performed live for 10 years now, and from my point of view, there are two distinct challenges with Jonīs vocals today.
1. The amount of energy used to hit the high notes, it costs a lot to get it right.
2. The direction of the energy. Once you have the proper energy needed for a given note, you need to direct it in a certain way.
Something happened between Destination anywhere and Crush, my guess is Jon didnīt sing that much in between + that the smoking MIGHT (and only might) have caused him to alter his technique to a certain degree. If you donīt practice powerful high notes you usually loose the sense for how much it actually takes to hit them. Itīs all about muscular memory, particularly when moving into the more extreme areas of the voice. Iīve seen singers take 1/2 a year of without any live singing (just acoustic stuff and fooling around, usually the belting stuff is left out on these occasions) and come back sounding like teenage girls on the high notes. It usually is fixed with a couple of weeks of very dedicated muscular conditioning and constantly working on the high notes to return.
During crush and bounce he was often using to little energy to get the powerful notes, and thatīs the main reason he was adding the "nasal" sound to it, singers call it twang. It is actually produced in the vocal tract but makes the sound nasal, the main point is that when twanging you donīt need nearly as much energy to hit notes as you would otherwise.
He has gotten better again, because he seems to be finding his way back to the right amounts of energy to hit powerful notes.
The problem now has become category 2, directing the energy. Heīs in my view doing enough now, but he is not directing it as precisely as he used to before the problems occured in the late 90īs. This becomes very clear on the clip of Hallelujah they recently recorded, a lot of energy but it sounds very strained all through even though the notes are fairly low on the scale. This is because heīs trying to push the notes higher, he has some tensions that prevents him from letting the note sing freely. Basically, I would call it overblowing, to much air pressure beneath the cords which means they canīt stretch freely.
As far as touring, it doesnīt wear a singer down in the sense one might think. The vocal cords are not muscles, just tissue that vibrate. And the human body is very good at repairing itself. The only thing that could happen is that you get nodes, which would cause a blind spot in the voice on certain notes. Thatīs probably not what happened to Jon, since he still hits lots of high notes on studio recordings and so on. Those would not be possible if he had had a severe problem with nodes (good example of node problems is Bonnie Tyler before and after her surgery..)
The age thing shouldnīt be an issue either, because it comes down to energy. And the man is in stellar shape, no doubt about it. With the muscular conditioning he has, there is no risk of not having the physical power to pull it off. It has everything to do with using the power and directing it.
To sing like Jon did in the eighties and early nineties is however not something that can be manufactured, to belt like that with rasp requires that you really feel it, otherwise the energy just wonīt be there.
Sometimes on more recent performances it looks like heīs thinking "Oh shit here comes the high note" instead of feeling the song and the lyrics. Itīs a mental game as well, and thatīs the prescription of activating a lot of unnecessary muscles, i.e. tension, which means that the energy is going to be directed in a less efficient manner.
My guess is the basic technical issue, + the fact that he probably deep down doesnīt want to express himself like he used to with all the screaming and the rasp and so on is the issue.
I firmly believe that he still could perform like he did in the these days era (he had great technique back then), if he got the issues straightened out and had the desire to do it.
Wow what a post, I just couldnīt stop writing, I had obviously thought a lot about this but never really let it out before
