Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Iceman
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Bleeding Purist
First of all..that song is really nothing but another edit of I'll Sleep When I'm Dead.
|
No, it's not. No similar chords, no similar progressions, different beat, different structure. It's really close to Dude Looks Like A Lady, but it hasn't got anything but the word "Dead" in common with ISWID.
Ice
|
Ice? This is a shock. Yes, it has a different beat and chord progression....but it DOES have similar structure, particularly in the chorus...it not just the lyical similarity. That isn't where I got it and initially before I really sat down and gave it a thorough listen....I said the same as you.
It's definately not a simple edit....I shouldn't have said that. It's basically a hybrid of another song idea and what was eventually used in Sleep When I'm Dead..that much I am absolutely sure of. It begins right at the chorus and I'm going to try to illustrate it:
You said you couldn't live without me
Til I'm six feet under
So why aren't you dead?
Baby I don't need a bed
Instead of six feet under you're in someone elses bed
Gonna live while I'm alive, sleep when I'm dead
Just one thing that I can't get through my head
Til they roll me over and lay my bones to rest
(skip "gonna live while i'm alive, sleep when I'm dead, sleep when I'm dead" band goes silent at this point in both songs and then)
You said you couldn't live without me
Gonna live while I'm alive
So why aren't you dead?
Sleep when I'm dead
(band comes back in)
Sing Sleep When I'm Dead's lyrics over the chorus and it's a bit more clear. It's definately not the exact same song..but there is no doubt it's the same idea morphed.