No I definitely wouldn't.

I became a fan soon after Crush came out but it wasn't BECAUSE of Crush. I actually couldn't stand It's My Life when it was popular. I only became a fan after I discovered their older music.

I think the same would be true with any of their albums since then. Don't get me wrong, I do really like a lot of the newer music. But not enough that it would make me a fan on its own.