View Single Post
 
Old 01-30-2005, 03:16 PM
jade82's Avatar
jade82 jade82 is offline
Senior Member
Hardest Part is the Night
 
Join Date: 06 Mar 2004
Location: England
Posts: 237
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Becky
I don't think there's enough material that Richie has written alone to compare his songwriting skills to Jon's. With Jon we have the bulk of his solo CDs, half of the Keep the Faith CD, and songs from each band CD that he wrote solo. With Richie, there are three songs in the entire catalogue that he wrote solo. So, I don' t believe there's enough of a sample to compare the two as songwriters. Who knows how much of Richie's solo CDs are the contribution of Dave Bryan or Richie Supa or Desmond Child etc.

Now if you want to compare Jon and Richie as a team to another team of songwriters, there are plenty of songs to judge them by. If you want to compare Jon to another solo songwriter, there's enough material to do so. But it's impossible to judge Richie as a songwriter because there isn't enough released material he wrote alone.Becky
Yep, i agree.
If Richie were the real genius and the real musical influence on the band then all of their albums would sound like his solo work, but they don't.

Jon has said plenty of times before that part of what made the band was that they all had different musical influences and they put these into the band. You can tell that Richie has had input into the band but it is not all his own work.
Reply With Quote