Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Beavoid
What am I on? Have I committed a sin in questioning the mighty Pearl Jam? Oh, well Fie upon me...Fie Fie upon me.
|
not at all - you just seem to harbor a lot of repressed anger that's all - either that or you are on drugs. :P
Quote:
|
What I am saying is if we are all being objective here, Vedder's voice is lightyears worse than Jon's.
|
the question was the best american band - not the band with the best vocal abilities. Out of the list given, I can only wholeheartedly agree with PJ being the no. 1 -- other than the fact that, as my friend would put it, Eddie Boytoy Vedder ditched his hometown girlfriend for a model - they truly have stayed true to their music, art, fans, themselves, etc... More so than any other band listed.
And I am not even a huge PJ fan.
That is my opinion only of course - and obviously that of all the other PJ voters that bothered to actually voice their opinion. And that is all the survey was based on - not vocal abilities, though I take a Vedder over a 'not being able to sing much anymore' Jon any day of the week.