I am torn myself, as I was typing the original post I was thinking of the 12 songs nobody had ever heard the Jovi's do live to add to my setlist, but then I started comparing it to the TD set and it's not as cut and dried as I originally thought. There are a lot of great unplayed or seldom played Jovi tracks but as a whole I am begining to doubt that 12 of them can stand up to the "all killler no filler" juggernaut of These Days. More thinking to do, glad I am not working today

my best 12 rarities:
edge of a broken heart
borderline
fields of fire
love is war
lets make it baby
judgement day
fear
knockin on heavens door
lonely at the top
breathe
all along the watchtower
i want you


Close runner ups:
social disease
cadillac man
like a rollin stone
bridge over troubled water
good guys don't always wear white


Also considered:
heart of america
gonna take you higher
99 in the shade
shooting star
never say die
the answer
levon
the sole truth
blame it on the love of rock and roll
if I was your mother
freebird
crazy
waltzing matilda
house of the rising sun
mrs robinson
try a little tenderness
respect
lifes too short for days like these
hush
signed sealed delivered
lean on me
here comes the sun
bitter wine
fighter for love
walking the dog
memphis lives in me
sylvia's mother