I cannnot vote .. both are great live ..technically I don't know much about music and cannot judge a musician skill except on an emotionnal level but my ears are pleased by their performances so I am happy .. now saying Dave is not having the rock feeling anymore because he is NOT DRESSED cool enough I am shocked to read that are you any serious ? it's almost girly to say something like that who cares what he wears .. come on ....
Dave is very cool on stage very activ very funny I don't see anything to complain about ...
and I just adore Hugh he is himself he is this way I think he is cool and very Hugh-ish

I have seen the guys live quite a lot .... I am not refereing to tv stuff but to real live shows