Jovitalk - Bon Jovi Fan Community
Home Register Members FAQ Mark Forums Read
 

Why is it okay for the band to rip off Soul Asylum but not others?

General BJ Discussion


Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1  
Old 01-20-2014, 05:16 AM
Captain_jovi's Avatar
Captain_jovi Captain_jovi is online now
Moderator
This Post Feels Right
 
Join Date: 31 Jul 2002
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
Age: 39
Gender: male
Posts: 13,752
Send a message via AIM to Captain_jovi Send a message via MSN to Captain_jovi
Default Why is it okay for the band to rip off Soul Asylum but not others?

I'm bringing this conversation over from another thread. Bon Jovi took the Soul Asylum song Runaway Train for Someday I'll be Saturday Night and we hold it in such wide regard. Why do we give a get out of jail free card for that and not from songs from the last decade?

Seb made the point of "Probably because that's considered a good song, while most of the recent stuff just isn't." but that just doesn't do it for me. Would everyone have to like the song enough for us to say "It's okay this isn't original work because what they did sounds great?"

Would love some thoughts.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Iceman View Post
Don't make the mistake of thinking that even 1% of Bon Jovi fans are like you, because they aren't. Don't think you know how Bon Jovi fans think. You don't. You know yourself. Stick to that.
Reply With Quote

  #2  
Old 01-20-2014, 05:25 AM
DryCounty's Avatar
DryCounty DryCounty is offline
Senior Member
These Days
 
Join Date: 26 Jun 2009
Location: Sweden
Gender: male
Posts: 2,739
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_jovi View Post
I'm bringing this conversation over from another thread. Bon Jovi took the Soul Asylum song Runaway Train for Someday I'll be Saturday Night and we hold it in such wide regard. Why do we give a get out of jail free card for that and not from songs from the last decade?

Seb made the point of "Probably because that's considered a good song, while most of the recent stuff just isn't." but that just doesn't do it for me. Would everyone have to like the song enough for us to say "It's okay this isn't original work because what they did sounds great?"

Would love some thoughts.
What exactly do you find so similar between the songs? The lyrical theme may be the same but in that case you could say that Carrie by Europe is the same song as Always, because both of them is about broken hearted love.

Again, Bon Jovi writes pop influenced rock music, though rock influenced pop music may lean more towards the truth these days. There are only a certain number of songs that can be written in the genre Bon Jovi is playing, at least since 2000. Some melodies may be similar, some arrangements may be like eachother but some of you guys are pushing the "Jon is stealing" theory to far.

The Beautiful World rip of How Far We've Come is pretty brutal though, can't be a coincidence.
__________________
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 01-20-2014, 06:01 AM
Captain_jovi's Avatar
Captain_jovi Captain_jovi is online now
Moderator
This Post Feels Right
 
Join Date: 31 Jul 2002
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
Age: 39
Gender: male
Posts: 13,752
Send a message via AIM to Captain_jovi Send a message via MSN to Captain_jovi
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DryCounty View Post
What exactly do you find so similar between the songs? The lyrical theme may be the same but in that case you could say that Carrie by Europe is the same song as Always, because both of them is about broken hearted love.

Again, Bon Jovi writes pop influenced rock music, though rock influenced pop music may lean more towards the truth these days. There are only a certain number of songs that can be written in the genre Bon Jovi is playing, at least since 2000. Some melodies may be similar, some arrangements may be like eachother but some of you guys are pushing the "Jon is stealing" theory to far.

The Beautiful World rip of How Far We've Come is pretty brutal though, can't be a coincidence.
Sure sure but this isn't me saying they sound alike. Play the demo of Saturday Night and Runaway Train back to back. Compounded by the fact that the engineer of it, Kevin Shirley I think it was, put on record that Jon walked in with the song and said to make it sound like that.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Iceman View Post
Don't make the mistake of thinking that even 1% of Bon Jovi fans are like you, because they aren't. Don't think you know how Bon Jovi fans think. You don't. You know yourself. Stick to that.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 01-20-2014, 08:14 AM
rocknation's Avatar
rocknation rocknation is offline
Senior Member
Something for the Posts
 
Join Date: 08 Sep 2002
Location: Undisclosed Location NJ
Gender: female
Posts: 3,058
Default

Tom Petty did a song called Runaway Trains, too, in 1987. Maybe he's the culprit.
__________________
rocknation

Remember how we used to talk about busting out? We'd break their hearts together...forever...



You and me and our old friends / hoping it would never end / holding on to never say goodbye...
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 01-20-2014, 09:50 AM
steel_horse75's Avatar
steel_horse75 steel_horse75 is offline
Senior Member
Price of posting
 
Join Date: 29 May 2007
Location: Klopp Army
Age: 49
Gender: male
Posts: 5,678
Default

This was 20 years ago. Move on
__________________
Wembley Arena 90, Wembley Arena 93, MK Bowl 93, Wembley Stadium 95, MK Bowl 96, Wembley Stadium 00, MK Bowl 01, Hyde Park 03, MK Bowl 06, o2 07, Twickenham 08, o2 10 (x2), Hyde Park 13, London Palladium 16, Wembley 19
Follow me: @iam_emmo
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 01-20-2014, 05:39 PM
Captain_jovi's Avatar
Captain_jovi Captain_jovi is online now
Moderator
This Post Feels Right
 
Join Date: 31 Jul 2002
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
Age: 39
Gender: male
Posts: 13,752
Send a message via AIM to Captain_jovi Send a message via MSN to Captain_jovi
Default

....Yeah you definitely missed the point of this.

I'm not harping on them for ripping off another band. I'm saying we're using "Well this song ripped off Tom Petty so they're liars" and "this song stole from the Civil Wars" as reasons to bash the band but the fact that 20 years ago they did the exact same thing and Saturday Night is loved so much. I wanted a debate on why we're okay with it sometimes and not others.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Iceman View Post
Don't make the mistake of thinking that even 1% of Bon Jovi fans are like you, because they aren't. Don't think you know how Bon Jovi fans think. You don't. You know yourself. Stick to that.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 01-20-2014, 06:20 PM
Alphavictim Alphavictim is offline
Senior Member
Jovi Freak
 
Join Date: 15 Sep 2005
Location: Germany
Age: 37
Gender: male
Posts: 3,490
Default

1. The theft was nowhere near as blatant.
2. Saturday Night is a good song.3
3. Saturday Night emapncipated itself from the source since it became a huge song itself and got its own identity. The Fighter is the last track on WAN, the one that ripped off Civil Wars. It's not a live classic, it's not a fan favorite, it's just an album track that has very little distinct features or identity.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 01-20-2014, 06:27 PM
Captain_jovi's Avatar
Captain_jovi Captain_jovi is online now
Moderator
This Post Feels Right
 
Join Date: 31 Jul 2002
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
Age: 39
Gender: male
Posts: 13,752
Send a message via AIM to Captain_jovi Send a message via MSN to Captain_jovi
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alphavictim View Post
1. The theft was nowhere near as blatant.
2. Saturday Night is a good song.3
3. Saturday Night emapncipated itself from the source since it became a huge song itself and got its own identity. The Fighter is the last track on WAN, the one that ripped off Civil Wars. It's not a live classic, it's not a fan favorite, it's just an album track that has very little distinct features or identity.
I hear what you're saying. To me I can't separate what makes a song good and what doesn't as I really enjoy both songs. Saturday Night was always going to be a single whereas The Fighter wasn't so knowing more people would hear the first than the latter makes it an odd choice to lift from another song for the sake of an album track. I don't think it becoming big gives it its own identity or makes people forget though. It could very well be the same situation with both Saturday Night and The Fighter. Jon heard a song he really enjoyed and wanted songs that sounded like it. One became a big single, one was for "him". I'm having trouble seeing why one is okay and the other is shameful.

I agree that it's not as blatant. The demo however is far more close to the original source. Does anyone have the original quote from the engineer of Saturday Night? I can scan it later if not.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Iceman View Post
Don't make the mistake of thinking that even 1% of Bon Jovi fans are like you, because they aren't. Don't think you know how Bon Jovi fans think. You don't. You know yourself. Stick to that.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 01-20-2014, 07:33 PM
Alphavictim Alphavictim is offline
Senior Member
Jovi Freak
 
Join Date: 15 Sep 2005
Location: Germany
Age: 37
Gender: male
Posts: 3,490
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_jovi View Post
I don't think it becoming big gives it its own identity or makes people forget though.
It worked for Bad Name. Or Michael Jackson's You Are Not Alone. Or half of Zeppelin's catalogue.

The bigger song is the one people think of when they hear a similiar melody or rhythm. This even goes for covers.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 01-20-2014, 07:36 PM
Captain_jovi's Avatar
Captain_jovi Captain_jovi is online now
Moderator
This Post Feels Right
 
Join Date: 31 Jul 2002
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
Age: 39
Gender: male
Posts: 13,752
Send a message via AIM to Captain_jovi Send a message via MSN to Captain_jovi
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alphavictim View Post
It worked for Bad Name. Or Michael Jackson's You Are Not Alone. Or half of Zeppelin's catalogue.

The bigger song is the one people think of when they hear a similiar melody or rhythm. This even goes for covers.
I agree. It almost makes you forget it was a take off. My question is more leaning towards this fandom. I think it's either okay that they take off other songs or its not. There's this imaginary middle ground since 2000 when we get up in arms that Jon (and Richie) stole from someone else but they've been doing it for decades. I guess it hit me that we can't be picky when they do it for songs we really like.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Iceman View Post
Don't make the mistake of thinking that even 1% of Bon Jovi fans are like you, because they aren't. Don't think you know how Bon Jovi fans think. You don't. You know yourself. Stick to that.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 05:45 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11.
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.