I pretty much stopped following BJ right around Crush time but I was a huge fan growing up so I couldn't resist the temptation to chime in

So, here's my list up until Crush:
Debut: She Don't Know Me (sounds sooo terribly out of place, might be ok on its own)
7800 Fahrenheit: King of the Mountain (might as well be their worst song ever - at least from the era that I'm knowledgeable about)
Slippery: Never Say Goodbye
NJ: Blood on Blood (I think this song's pretty sacred around here, so I'm sorry but I always hated the insincerity of JBJ in that song - sounds very much forced to me, the whole I'm-just-a-rock-singer-in-a-band persona)
KTF: Bed of Roses
Crossroad: Always
These Days: Bitter Wine
Crush: Thank You For Loving Me (there might be worse ones but I don't remember most of this album and I remember hating this song with a passion)
Stranger In This Town: One Light Burning
Destination Anywhere: Cold Hard Heart