Would This Have Made For a Good Album?

1. Make a Memory
2. Whole Lot of Leavin'
3. Any Other Day
4. Broken Promise Land
5. Love's the Only Rule
6. Happy Now
7. I'm With You
8. That's What the Water Made Me
9. What's Left of Me
10. This is Love, This is Life

So, for me, about 1 in 4 songs that the band release have any staying power. I didn't realise that until I tried doing this.

That's 3 songs an album...the rest is just mediocre.

1. That's What the Water Made Me
2. Any Other Day
3. What's Left of Me
4. (You Want To) Make a Memory
5. Whole Lot of Leaving
6. Lost Highway
7. No Apologies
8. Superman Tonight
9. Amen
10. Love's the Only Rule
11. When We Were Beautiful
12. The Fighter

I think that's pretty solid, but I wouldn't replace any of the complete albums with it. It's still missing a few decent songs.

1. Brokenpromisedland
2. Whole lot of leaving
3. Make a memory
4. I´m with you
5. When we were beautiful
6. That´s what the water made me
7. Any other day
8. Thick as thives
9. Beautiful world
10. Room at the end of the world
11. Seat next to you
12. Love´s the only rule

Since I don´t like any of the new songs from the Greatest Hits I just went with the songs from the studio albums

I like it - well done! I'm not picky about the order of songs on an album as I often shuffle them up on my iPod.

In no particular order:

1.This is Love, This is Life
2.I'm With You
3.You Want To Make A Memory
4.Superman Tonight
5.Love's The Only Rule
6.Any Other Day
7.Because We Can
8.That's What The Water Made Me
9.Lost Highway
10.When We Were Beautiful
11.Any Other Day
12.With These Two Hands

1. That's What The Water Made Me
2. We Weren't Born To Follow
3. Beautiful World
4. (You Want To) Make A Memory
5. What Do You Got?
6. Whole Lot Of Leavin'
7. Thorn In My Side
8. We Got It Going On (minus cheesy "My Country Cousin" shit and replaced with "To Hear You Scream")
9. Any Other Day
10. What's Left Of Me
11. With These Two Hands
12. Love's The Only Rule
13. Thick As Thieves
14. Superman Tonight

This could be a kick ass album!!

1. That's What the Water Made Me
2. Thorn In My Side
3. Make a Memory
4. I'm With You
5. This Is Love, This Is Life
6. Superman Tonight
7. What's Left of Me
8. Beautiful World
9. Whole Lot of Leavin
10. Love's the Only Rule
11. Walk Like a Man
12. Lonely

BONUS
13. Lost Highway
14. Happy Now
15. Pictures of You

Add With These Two Hands and I agree!

1. Lost Highway
2. Summertime
3. (You Want To) Make A Memory
4. Whole Lot Of Leaving
5. Walk Like A Man
6. I'm With You
7. We Got It Going On
8. Brokenpromiseland
9. 'Til We Ain't Strangers Anymore
10. The Last Night
11. One Step Closer
12. I Love This Town

And this would be mine, in this order:

1. We Weren’t Born To Follow
2. That’s What The Water Made Me
3. Superman Tonight
4. The More Things Change
5. Pictures of You
6. Happy Now
7. Whole Lot of Leavin
8. Til We Ain’t Strangers Anymore
9. Brokenpromiseland
10. Any Other Day
11. Beautiful World
12. (You Want To) Make A Memory
13. When We Were Beautiful
14. Into The Echo
15. Love’s The Only Rule

Bonustrack:
16. With These Two Hands

I salute you,
Thunderstrucker