Originally Posted by JackieBlue

Is that rhetorical? Because I have no idea what you would do.


You didn't ask me, but if that were the case I'd tell you the troll is a copycat who stole the identity and style of another fan.

Rosa3 and I go way back on other boards. We rarely agree on everything and I agree with you that nobody has any business telling ppl what they should post; or say that they aren't good fans if they are critcal.

But I will say this: it's a rare fan, especially among those who are pro-Jon or pro-Richie, who can even acknowledge that there are 2 sides. The main line of defense for some of them is to point out flaws or weaknesses in the other guy so their guy comes out on top by comparison. Some fans on both sides actually seem to spend more time digging up dirt or bad press on "the other one" than they spend looking for real news about their hero. Kinda sick.

Rosa3 isn't like that. She's one of the few fans I know who can defend Jon without trashing Richie (or the other way around). In fact, she rarely says anything bad about anyone altho she can make critical comments to people at times, like she has here. Personally, I'll take the more direct method every time. If someone doesn't agree with me, I'd much rather they talk to me, not about me.

Just had to say that...

Carry on!