Quote:
Originally Posted by bj4ever
I know the songs are tuned half a step down live (some like ITA are even more), so I was wondering why they haven't tried a full step down for all the songs to see if it would help.
I'm no vocalist so I have no idea but I'm surprised this hasn't happened yet.
|
Lowering keys takes the power out of songs. ( Yes, it's not cause a lot of heavy metal has D or even C tunings that low keys are equal to power)
Especially for guitars - tuning half a step to one step down is acceptable, but lower will make guitars sound bad. To go lower, it would mean songs would have to be transposed into complete different keys with different chords, but then again, some riffs would have to be played on different strings and it would make them sound completely different.
So - there's a limit to lowering the key of a song. AND - Jon's problem is in the mids. So it wouldn't really help a lot.
EDIT: Actually : Jon has been singing many songs a full step lower - problem is : the band still plays only half a step down
LOL