As a fan of both - I would probably go to see Bon Jovi. Fogerty is fantastic but his setlists tend to stay the same - and I'm not talking about similar - literally the same. The only additions are from whatever his latest album is and I don't care for his latest. It's too country for me - seriously - same complaint LOL.

On the other hand I have seen Fogerty a lot since he started back touring in 1998 and I saw him way back when also. So if you've not seen him live he certainly puts on a hell of a show.