Is it all about setlists?....I guess it might come down to expectations.
It's hard, I think, to 'debate' it...some people have only seen the band once or twice [like me]...others have seen them regularly [say 5-6 shows per tour] over several years...others have seen the band into the 100's of shows. Because I haven't seen them perform many times, I don't have that comparative perspective. I do see the point of view though, of those that have seen the band perform many, many times - particularly those who have seen, say with this tour, 6, 7, 8+ shows - if the band 'raise the bar' [especially when looking at the most recent previous tour], and you are present at shows when that bar got 'raised', I think it probably raises the expectation for following shows as well...even if you don't think about it consciously.
Likewise, for people who have only seen the band once or twice, there are expectations, but maybe more based on the 'rush' of actually going, actually being there, finally seeing the band live. I know when I saw the band the first time [March 2001, Melb], my expectations were more about the fact that at that time I was an FC member and that meant early entry, and that meant being near/up the front [and I learnt my lesson and NEVER again] - as for the band - hearing them play live for the first time was awesome, so the set list wasn't in my thoughts. When I saw then in Perth this year, yeah, I had some expectations [especially based on the reviews from friends who saw them in Melb/Sydney] - was I disappointed? If you had been able to show me the setlist for Perth's gig before the show, I probably would have said 'yeah, a bit'....but no, I/we weren't, because over half the songs we heard that night, we'd never heard live before anyway.
For me, it's the general atmosphere around you and the actual performance of the band, the interaction or connection they make, that makes the show something to really remember...but like I said at the start, my perspective is based on only seeing them twice, seven years apart.
S.
__________________
"Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe" - Einstein
"Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity"
|