No it's not. His argument is that Bon Jovi are nothing without Richie. My argument is that they're managing alright without him. I've broken it down in a way that shows my point in an effective, if crude, way. I did it like this as I believe a blunt, base comment may have more of an effect in this argument than something like, I don't know, reason.

And while we're at it, show a little class and express yourself in a more positive way than using a word such as 'retarded'. Disgusting.