These would be all the setlists I've seen live (Have them all saved on my computer.....what, I'm not mental =p) . I guess decide for yourself what's "rare". Some are obvious, but some where rare for that particular tour.

August 7, 2003, Giants Stadium
1. Bounce
2. You Give Love A Bad Name
3. Undivided
4. Everyday
5. Livin' On A Prayer
6. Captain Crash & The Beauty Queen From Mars
7. Keep The Faith
8. Wanted Dead Or Alive
9. Can't Help Falling In Love (a capella)
10. Bed Of Roses
11. It's My Life
12. Runaway
13. Just Older
14. Someday I'll Be Saturday Night
15. Joey
16. I'll Be There For You (Richie on lead vocals)
17. Hook Me Up
18. Born To Be My Baby
19. I'll Sleep When I'm Dead
20. Raise Your Hands

Encore:
21. I Got The Girl
22. I'd Die For You
23. Bad Medicine
24. Shout

December 21, 2005, Continental Airlines Arena
1. Last Man Standing
2. You Give Love A Bad Name
3. Complicated
4. Born To Be My Baby
5. Story Of My Life
6. I'll Sleep When I'm Dead
7. Runaway
8. The Radio Saved My Life Tonight
9. Just Older
10. I Won't Back Down
11. Have A Nice Day
12. Who Says You Can't Go Home
13. It's My Life
14. I'll Be There For You (TLFR version)
15. Blaze Of Glory (acoustic)
16. Always (TLFR version)
17. Captain Crash & The Beauty Queen From Mars
18. Bad Medicine
19. Raise Your Hands
20. Livin' On A Prayer

Encore #1:
21. Welcome To Wherever You Are
22. Last Cigarette
23. Treat Her Right
24. Blood On Blood
25. I Wish Everyday Could Be Like Christmas
26. Wanted Dead Or Alive

July 18, 2006, Giants Stadium(Lightning shortened show)
1. Rockin' In The Free World
2. You Give Love A Bad Name
3. Bounce
4. Born To Be My Baby
5. Story Of My Life
6. I'll Sleep When I'm Dead
7. Runaway
8. Captain Crash & The Beauty Queen From Mars
9. It's My Life
10. Wanted Dead Or Alive
11. In These Arms
12. Bed Of Roses (TLFR version)
13. I'll Be There For You (Richie Sambora on lead vocals)
14. Someday I'll Be Saturday Night
15. Have A Nice Day
16. Bad Medicine
17. Raise Your Hands
18. Who Says You Can't Go Home

Encore:
19. Livin' On A Prayer

October 28, 2007, Prudential Center:
1. Lost Highway
2. You Give Love A Bad Name
3. Runaway
4. Summertime
5. Blood On Blood
6. Born To Be My Baby
7. Whole Lot Of Leavin’
8. (You Want To) Make A Memory
9. We Got It Goin’ On (with Big & Rich)
10. It's My Life
11. Captain Crash & The Beauty Queen From Mars
12. Bad Medicine
13. These Days (Richie Sambora on lead vocals)
14. Living In Sin
14. Right Side Of Wrong
15. Lay Your Hands On Me
16. Have A Nice Day
17. The Radio Saved My Life Tonight
18. Keep The Faith
~ Sympathy For The Devil
19. Livin' On A Prayer

Encore:
20. Someday I'll Be Saturday Night
21. Wanted Dead Or Alive
22. Who Says You Can’t Go Home

November 9 , 2007, Prudential Center
1. Lost Highway
2. Summertime
3. The Last Night
4. Whole Lot Of Leavin’
5. (You Want To) Make A Memory
6. Everybody's Broken
7. We Got It Going On
8. Any Other Day
9. Till We Ain't Strangers Anymore
10. I Love This Town
11. Seat Next To You
12. One Step Closer

13. Livin' On A Prayer
14. You Give Love A Bad Name
15. Raise Your Hands
16. Runaway
17. It's My Life
18. Born To Be My Baby
19. Have A Nice Day
20. Lay Your Hands On Me
21. I'll Sleep When I'm Dead
22. Bad Medicine
23. Who Says You Can't Go Home

Encore:
24. I'll Be There For You (Jon on vocals)
25. Someday I'll Be Saturday Night
26. Wanted Dead Or Alive
27. Keep The Faith

November 10 , 2007, Prudential Center
1. You Give Love A Bad Name
2. Raise Your Hands
3. Runaway
4. Story Of My Life
5. Whole Lot Of Leavin’
6. Lost Highway
7. I Love This Town
8. Born To Be My Baby
9. We Got It Goin’ On
10. It's My Life
11. Keep The Faith
12. Bad Medicine
13. These Days (Richie Sambora on lead vocals)
14. (You Want To) Make A Memory
15. Bed Of Roses (This Left Feels Right Version)
16. Lay Your Hands On Me
17. Have A Nice Day
18. Who Says You Can't Go Home
19. Livin' On A Prayer

Encore I:
20. I'll Sleep When I'm Dead
22. Wanted Dead Or Alive

Encore II:
23. Twist & Shout
24. Treat Her Right

February 12, 2008, Hammerstein Ballroom (Concert for the Cure~Charity Benefit)
Richie Sambora (acoustic)
1. Made In America
2. It's My Life
3. Fallen From Graceland
4. Stranger In This Town (electric)

Bon Jovi
1. A Little Help From My Friends
2. Bad Name
3. Born To Be My Baby
4. Lost Highway
5. Whole Lot of Leavin'
6. Wanted Dead or Alive
7. In These Arms
8. Bad Medicine (with Shout)
9. Who Says You Can't Go Home
10. Livin' on a Prayer