I'll try to make my ideal set list as realistic as possible:

1) LYHOM
2) Follow or Happy Now
3) Bad Name
4) Runaway
5) Only Lonely/In and out of love
6) Lost Highway or WLOL NOT both!
7) WWWB
In these Arms
9) Superman
10) WGIGO/One wild night/Bounce
11) Bad Medicine
12) IML
13) Homebound Train
14) IBTFY
15) Always/BOR/Living in sin
16) Blaze of Glory
17) Something for the pain/Saturday night
1 Faith/Hey God
19) HAND
20) Who says
21) Dry County/I believe
22) Loves the only Rule
Encore
23) Just Older/Next 100 years/Blood on Blood
24) Broken Promiseland/Thorn in my side
25) Wanted
26) Prayer

I'd be very happy with any of this combination. I don't think there is anything completely unrealistic here...