[spunkywho]

Originally Posted by DevilsSon

I don't believe it will come out. I don't even hope it will come out anymore. Axl is a wreck.

I'm with you there!

[Arash]

Originally Posted by DevilsSon

Buckethead ,who I consider a genius, left...

I agree with you that he was a genius.

[Supersonic]

Aloha !

Originally Posted by Arash

I agree with you that he was a genius.

I'm not sure if I consider him a genius. Sure, the guy can play very, very fast, but from what I've heard it's all fast technical stuff and no emotion in his playing, which makes it a bit dull for me.

Salaam Aleikum,
Sebastiaan

[DevilsSon]

Originally Posted by Supersonic

Aloha !

I'm not sure if I consider him a genius. Sure, the guy can play very, very fast, but from what I've heard it's all fast technical stuff and no emotion in his playing, which makes it a bit dull for me.

Salaam Aleikum,
Sebastiaan

That means you haven't heard any whole album.

Do me a favour and buy COLMA which is my fave Buckethead album. He could give even Mark Knopfler feeling lessons...

[Dave 1986]

I'm not bothered at all if it ever gets released to be honest. And IF it does, I'd still be in no rush to buy it. All I could say is after a 10 year delay, it better be good.

[Calyx]

As much as I love the music that the original line up released 15 or so years ago, Im not really sold on this being a "Guns 'n Roses" album. I'll probably buy it out of curiosity but I can't really say Im anticipating it all that much.

With only Axl being the only remaining member of the original line up, this album is really just him expressing himself and using the GNR name to make money. I'm sure if he changed the band name then not as many people would care, but because it's "GNR", then people believe its going to be something special and buy it almost believing its the same band. Without the same guys writing these songs, then how can it possibly sound the same as the earlier material.

It's no different than Jon releasing his solo work under the "Bon Jovi" name. As much as I like Jon's solo work, it is the band (particuarly Richie) who contributes with the songwriting and together they created the songs that this band is famous for... Jon is a member of the band but he is not
"the" band...

I'm sure Axl will be able to come up with some decent, possibly even great songs, I just think a gimmick that he is using the name of a band that died years ago to get people to buy it.

[Calyx]

As much as I love the music that the original line up released 15 or so years ago, Im not really sold on this being a "Guns 'n Roses" album. I'll probably buy it out of curiosity but I can't really say Im anticipating it all that much.

With only Axl being the only remaining member of the original line up, this album is really just him expressing himself and using the GNR name to make money. I'm sure if he changed the band name then not as many people would care, but because it's "GNR", then people believe its going to be something special and buy it almost believing its the same band. Without the same guys writing these songs, then how can it possibly sound the same as the earlier material.

It's no different than Jon releasing his solo work under the "Bon Jovi" name. As much as I like Jon's solo work, it is the band (particuarly Richie) who contributes with the songwriting and together they created the songs that this band is famous for... Jon is a member of the band but he is not
"the" band...

I'm sure Axl will be able to come up with some decent, possibly even great songs, I just think a gimmick that he is using the name of a band that died years ago to get people to buy it.

[Calyx]

As much as I love the music that the original line up released 15 or so years ago, Im not really sold on this being a "Guns 'n Roses" album. I'll probably buy it out of curiosity but I can't really say Im anticipating it all that much.

With only Axl being the only remaining member of the original line up, this album is really just him expressing himself and using the GNR name to make money. I'm sure if he changed the band name then not as many people would care, but because it's "GNR", then people believe its going to be something special and buy it almost believing its the same band. Without the same guys writing these songs, then how can it possibly sound the same as the earlier material.

It's no different than Jon releasing his solo work under the "Bon Jovi" name. As much as I like Jon's solo work, it is the band (particuarly Richie) who contributes with the songwriting and together they created the songs that this band is famous for... Jon is a member of the band but he is not
"the" band...

I'm sure Axl will be able to come up with some decent, possibly even great songs, I just think a gimmick that he is using the name of a band that died years ago to get people to buy it.

[allmike]

Originally Posted by Supersonic

Aloha !

Nope, only Axl Rose and Dizzy Reed (the keyboardplayer they added on the Use Your Illusion Tour) are in the current line up.

Axl Rose [ Vocals, Guitar ]
Dizzy Reed [ Keyboards ]
Tommy Stinson [ Bass ]
Brain [ Drums ]
Robin Finck [ Guitar ]
Richard Fortus [ Guitar ] ++

Paul Tobias [ Guitar ] +
Buckethead [ Guitar ] !
Josh Freese [ Drums ] *

[ Notes: ]

+ = was not touring with GN'R in 2002. Status in band is unknown. Replaced by Richard Fortus.
++ = replaced Paul Tobias in GN'R. Has recorded guitar parts on the albums.
* = has left GN'R (Josh went on tour with A Perfect Circle). According to Axl, Josh will be on the album.
! = left the band in early 2004

Copied from www.heretodaygonetohell.com

Salaam Aleikum,
Sebastiaan

Without Slash, they can't defnetly call it G'nR

[Mousebounce]

Without Slash, they can't defnetly call it G'nR

It would be nice to have him, but they are still quite good without him.