Quote:
Originally Posted by TheOriginalJez
Did you see the It's My Life thing they did where Phil didn't show up until the solo? If there's a decent solo in this song then I'll agree on that point. Everyone just did their little bit. But at this point I don't think Hugh's played bass and I don't think Tico's played drums. I haven't heard ANY keys to suggest Dave's involved at all.
It's not just creative differences it's just a lacklustre performance all round on that 30 seconds.
|
I haven't seen it yet; but that doesn't surprise me.
From what I've seen, Phil-X doesn't seem to be nearly as excited about the band or the album as he used to be.
I get what you're saying, and I'm not arguing one side or the other. It's just that for all the songs I've seen (with the exception of American Reckoning), the credits list each of the band members, including Jon and Shanks, as "Associated Performer" and I have no reason to dispute that. But then, credits can mean everything or nothing.
My point is that I don't get the feeling that the band has had any more influence on this album (or on THINFS, for that matter) than they had on any of the other more recent releases, despite all the hype about being a "band album". So I don't understand why Jon keeps pushing that point.
But maybe RDK is right and it's just the difference between what Jon means by "band album" and what I thought it meant.