Quote:
Originally Posted by Johny
My two cents about Shine.. I know we like to speculate here a lot but couldn't it just be another song with the same name? Shine - that's one word, no uncommon and Jon is known to revisit song titles. I get the resemblance to WAN ballads but I think such song would end up Burning Bridges. When crap like We All Fall Down made it. And it isn't that special to be saved not the next album but the one after and shifted to be a bonus track.
Is the source from 2013 a reliable one? And I'm too lazy to check if the combination of songwriters was common at that time.
|
Others would've argued the same thing about Diamond Ring. If it's a song important to Jon and he didn't see it fitting on WAN and didn't wanna waste it on BB, it's very well possible that it was used now. The 2013 source is what the management or whatever officially had registered in a song data base, so this song was around back then.
Of course, Jon likes to reuse some titles like his knack for Open All Night, but too much here feels like it came from some way back.