Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_jovi
...
My point was more referring to the accusation that John Shanks and Jon did the work and then called in the rest of the guys and that was part of what caused the rift between Jon and Richie. Richie not making it onto a band album song and the secondary live guitarist doing it instead to me insinuates there could have been problems there before Shanks was really 100 percent involved with the band. It could have been logistical, there could have been a very good reason he didn't play on that particular song but because it was a band album, not recording it until he could play on it strikes me as odd.
Phil X playing on the Greatest Hits is such an interesting thing that I am still unable to piece together. WDYG was produced by Howard Benson who typically used Phil as his his go-to session guitarist. Once Phil officially got involved with the band, Jon had said Phil wasn't someone he knew minus him playing on Levon and touring with Aldo Nova, which would mean Phil's session work didn't even involve Jon/the band being there...
I wonder when the decision was made to bring Bobby on full time. He was at both Borgata shows in 2003 and 2004 (or was it 2004 and 2005) and the promo appearances for the box set.
|
According to Wiki Bobby was brought in to tour TLFR in 2003.
I know Jon and Phil-X knew each other from
Blood on the Bricks in '98; but I thought it was Shanks who recommended him, either for WGIGO, or as Richie's fill-in when he was in rehab in 2011. I don't know about Benson.
I think the rift was there before Shanks. The only reason I made the connection with "Living life wasn't such a fight until you came along" was that if Bobby was right and problems were already brewing, I can see how Shanks assuming, or being given, more of Richie's territory might have made matters worse (from Richie's POV, since it's his song we were discussing).
It could be on Richie, or it could be on Jon, or (most likely) it could have been any combination. We seem to be hearing more and more from Jon, these days, that would indicate that Richie has "always" been unreliable; and we know that Jon doesn't always have the patience of Job when it comes to doing what he wants to in the studio, when he wants to do it, regardless of anyone else's schedule. We also know that he didn't wait on Phil to record THINFS, even though he apparently intended for him to be the guitarist.
(Funny somewhat-related sidebar: I've been listening to the Alice Tully event bonjovi90 posted; and apparently what originally gave birth to the "Frankie" line in IML was Jon coming back from making U571 and saying, "Dammit, I'm gonna make movies when I
want, and I'm gonna to
tell you guys when I want to make movies, like Frank Sinatra said, 'I did it my way'...(??)... it's MY life!")
Back OT: I wasn't saying anything about WHY Shanks' role grew; just that, according to Jon, it did. But I also find it odd that it's only recently that Jon is saying that; since, as Becky points out, in the past he has only talked about how
involved Richie was. But now, suddenly, it was all Jon and Shanks. Richie and the other guys just popped in as needed.
I'm not sure how much of that is fact and how much is posturing to downplay Richie's past contributions; but with Jon it's hard to tell. And quite honestly, I get the feeling that he likes it that way. It has to make it easier for him to rewrite history to suit whatever his current agenda might be.
I didn't know that there were more people like Irene who think Shanks tried to edge Richie out. I just remember the one tweet. I didn't even know who she was until someone, maybe you, posted it and said she had been involved with the band's PR, and then Richie's. Later, I noticed that she wrote the liner notes/history for the NJ Deluxe re-release. So it sounds like she may have some insight; but I'm not sure if you're saying that you disagree with that Twitter group, or think they're making too much of it, or are just throwing it into the hopper with all the other variables.