Spoiler alert. Not sure if what I'm posting is revealing of much, but whatevs.

I guess I'm in the super minority here, but I like most of what I heard (except Amen, The Fighter, and Army of One, but those were all duds to me before this).

I'm With You sounds just fine, I think. The only autotune I notice is in the verses, but it's bearable.
Pictures of You sounds cool.
Water sounds just as good as the live versions.
What's Left of Me sounds just as good as the live versions, too, if not better.
Thick as Thieves is kinda boring.
Beautiful World sounds interesting, I'm eager to hear the full version.
Room at the End of the World sounds very mystic.
These Two Hands has silly lyrics.
Into the Echo sounds nice, too (though the echo on the word "echo" is kinda cheesy and cliche).

I think I'm gonna like this record quite a bit more than The Circle.