Damned was GREAT, audience was wild and Novocaine was also pretty memorable even though that wasn't part of the original plan but lot of people sang along with the chorus, there are many BJ fans in our school.
But I have to say that Wild Is The Wind was far the best cover we played that night. The intro went on like 5 minutes. We once used to play that song but it was about half an year ago so our lead-guitarist had to improvise a lot but it was so cool... solo and everything, the song went on almost 15 minutes!