pop idol discussion

had michelle been skinny and not bad lookign would she have won it?

i have to think no. considering the size of her, she doesn't have that great a voice. someone her size should have a massive voice whereas she wasnt even the best out of the last 10. i think alot of people took the size of her into account way too much and made themselves believe she was way better than everyone else when for the most part minus sam and roxanne they were all karaoke singers.

discuss......

i watched them both perform then came up here so i didnt even know who won till i just saw this post lol so it was the dude?

ok well ill watch some of the crap on AOL in a few mins and get back to you

what about rik waller? now he had a fantastic voice and he was way bigger than michelle. ill be honest and say i ahve no idea what michelle's voice sounds like but surely if what you're sayin is true wouldn't we have seen in in rik's case too?

rik waller didn't win because he had to drop out with a throat infection.

oh right thanks. but wasnt one of the judges really against him being there because of his size? i dont know...did all the judges like michelle? seems like double standards to me

She has a terrific voice - she was easily the most talented finalist.

sorry mate but if u can honestly say u think she was better than sam and roxanne and a couple more of them then ur wrong. most of them including her were nothign u couldnt find in any pub singing karaoke.

good voice yes, average for a good singer, great nope.

I only watched the final - she is far better than a karoake singer & if u think Mark was better - u need some syringes in those ears

I agree she was way better than Mark....but there is no way she was as good as Sam or Chris even.

Sam should have won it. He was the best.

Yep I agree.

This series hasnt been anywhere near as good as the last one when Will won. People havnt been voting on talent, theyve voted for those who they sorry for. Jims right, the only real pop idols were Sam and Roxanne.