had michelle been skinny and not bad lookign would she have won it?

i have to think no. considering the size of her, she doesn't have that great a voice. someone her size should have a massive voice whereas she wasnt even the best out of the last 10. i think alot of people took the size of her into account way too much and made themselves believe she was way better than everyone else when for the most part minus sam and roxanne they were all karaoke singers.

discuss......