Isn't it odd that Mary Ann has such a fit about her right to wear loud perfume but she seemingly has no problem denying Susan of this same right?? Maybe you should point that out to her...otherwise I agree with the others: get the statement and let the chips fall where they may. It isn't your fault that you have problems with perfumes and scented candles, and it isn't something you can change. If she can't get over it, maybe she should move her desk in to the tiny office after all.