Not sure it's Jimmy Eat World... There's only one song I looked through again to make sure. Nothing off any the latest album or Bleed American. The only song that contains lyrics about "stars" is "For Me This Is Heaven" off of Clarity. The lyric goes like this...

"The first star I see may not be a star.
We can't do a thing but wait."


Do you know that is infact by Jimmy Eat World??

Ryan