Is there a great album between BB and THINFS?
 

If you take the best from each album, I believe you could get a great album. I would call it "burning houses" and the cover would be the rooted house, surrounded by (but oblivious to) raging flames. Here is the tracklist:
1: Devil's in the temple
2: Teardrop to the sea
3: this house is not for sale
4: living with the ghost
5: who would you die for
6: New year's day
7: Labour of love
8: Fingerprints
9: Rollercoaster
10. Real love
11: We don't run
12: All hail the king

Perhaps replace New Years Day with Blind Love or Scars on This Guitar and that's the same list I'd make

There's no need for Blind Love and Real Love to be on the same album.

Replace All Hail The King with Born Again Tomorrow and that's a pretty nice package. Probably fit Knockout in there as well somehow, and it's cool.

This House is almost perfect to me, I would put Life Is Beautiful instead of Labor Of Love and Who Would You Die For instead of New Year's Day

Blind Love is better than Real Love so I'd take that off

My choice for a tracklist would be:

THIS HOUSE IS NOT FOR SALE
WE DON'T RUN
A TEARDROP TO THE SEA
SATURDAY NIGHT GAVE ME SUNDAY MORNING
BORN AGAIN TOMORROW
ROLLER COASTER
THE DEVIL'S IN THE TEMPLE
SCARS ON THIS GUITAR
I WILL DRIVE YOU HOME
GOD BLESS THIS MESS
REUNION

I didn't like "Saturday night" for some reason and then it hit me - they ripped it off Nickelback. Gross! One of the lowest possible points of their career IMO.

I think putting all the extra tracks from different versions of THINFS, 2-3 songs from BB, "Scars" and "Labor" would make a great record. It would need a better producer too though, to take off the excessive polish.

In no particular order:
- Color Me In
- We Don't Run
- Goodnight NY
- Scars on this Guitar
- Fingerprints
- Touch of Gray
- Labor of Love
- Blind Love
- Who Would You Die For
- I Will Drive You Home
- A Teardrop To The Sea
- Life Is Beautiful

that's TOTALLY my list, man! :D

I think that joining what I like most of both I have a satisfactory album, but I would not say it's a great album.

My Tracklist:

01 A Teardrop To The Sea
02 We Don't Run
03 This House Is Not For Sale
04 Knockout
05 Labor Of Love
06 Born Again Tomorrow
07 The Devils In The Temple
08 Who Would you Die For
09 Fingerprints
10 God Bless this Mess
11 Saturday Night Gave Me Sunday Morning
12 Take Back The Night
Bonus
13 I'm Your Man
14 New Years Day
15 Touch Of Grey