Official American Idol Thread
 

Post anything that is related to the greatest reality tv show here. Ok, maybe not the greatest but at least it doesn't have people bitchin against each other *cough*cough*survivor*cough* and it does judge talent to a certain extent.

Whattt???!??!! Nobody watches this show??? Come on!!!!!
:mad:

I do. I do. :lol:

I didn't watch the first one, but I'm addicted this time. And tonight it's on at the same time as Survivor, so I guess I'll have to watch one and tape the other. Then again, tonight's whole tv schedule could be pre-empted.

Last night I thought Trenyce had the best performance. The weakest was Carmen.

Carmen wasn't good, but she wasn't the weakest. I hope she will make it to next week because among the female contestants, I'm rooting for her!

Ruben and Clay totally dominated. These two sounded amazing, unbelieveable. If I were Simon, I would've stopped the contest and signed both.

Trenyce has a great voice but the thing is, she's one of those Whitney/Toni Braxton/Mariah Carey type and there have been too many of those already.

I think Julia will be voted off today. She should have had fun singing Flashdance but it didn't seem that way. Which is really bad. Some other contestants that I thought didn't sound good last night: Charles (this guy is really average), Corey (singing high notes is not really his forte) and Kimberly (the blonde one) who did not sing much.

The other Kimberly did well. Ditto Joshua. However, I can never enjoy Ricky's voice. For some reason, his voice always has this vibrato effect that annoys me to no end.

its just a copy of the British one

Which Was Shit

I thought it was funny how Simon, who hates everything, had to try to find something nice to say about Carmen, since she was his wildcard. ;) She was better last week so she might have enough fans to keep her on.

I know! And neither one has the American Idol look.

I'm not really a fan of that style of music, but even I couldn't deny that she has a powerful voice.

Was Julia the one who looked really uncomfortable? I almost fell asleep during Charles' song and I was a bit disappointed in Corey. I've liked his performances on previous weeks. The blonde Kimberly, she was the "Shoop Shoop" song, with all the background vocals? Not a good choice.

The other Kimberly, she was at the end? If so, yeah she was better this week. Joshua was ok, but I wasn't particularly impressed with the country twang. I can't even remember Ricky, so I guess he didn't impress me.

Do you live in the US? Did you vote? If so, who for? I'm in Canada, and we can't vote, but if I could I probably would have gone for Ruben, Clay or Trenyce, based on last night's performances.

i hope the REALLY big dude wins....he's awesome!!!!

WOOO HOOOO CARMEN SURVIVES!!!!

Charles was voted out. He was just so so, he can sing pretty good but everything else is average.

I'm surprised Corey was in the bottom 3.

Indeed he is. If the winner is not him or Clay (the dorky looking dude), it would be a blasphemy!

Wooo hooo Carmen survives!!!!! Go Carmen! I understand Simon's view because of the reason he picked her as the 'wildcard'. She can sing, and she looks good too. Simon is looking for the total package.

Yeah, but the voices... my goodness.

Yeah Julia was the one butchering Flashdance. She survived, I can't believe it. Charles' been average all along and he was booted just now. I guess his stage presence is a bit whacked. He can sing decent but that's about it. I am surprised Corey is in the bottom 3 since he's a pretty boy. And yes Kimberly did the Shoop Shoop song.


Yes that other Kimberly was the last and she actually has a very nice voice (I prefer hers over Treynece). Joshua survived (I think he has many fans already). Ricky is the dude who's always smiling.

I live in the US but I'm such a lazy ass I didn't vote but if I were to vote, I'd give it to Carmen. I wouldn't need to vote for Ruben or Clay they are unstoppable already but I'd really love Carmen to make it to top 4.