This week's Official American Idol Thread
 

Alright fooz, let's discuss the great show.

CARMEN IS HOT :)

And Kimberly C is too! :)

Other than that, I think generally this week's contestants did well except for maybe Julia and Ricky. I hope either one goes first.

Goddamn, did Olivia Newton John have plastic surgery or something? She looked so freaking young, it can't be her!

yup

yup

i hope it Julia.........she's isn't that great IMO

I thought they were all pretty bad. Except the Marine, he did really well.

Kimberly is good, but Carmen can't really hold a tune. She is cute, I will give you that. :D

Plus, the black guy with the really high voice..ugh!!

Who is the marine? I haven't been watching that long.

Julia is very pretty, but it's obvious she's really nervous and not that strong of a voice.

Carmen is very gorgeous too, and she has something. But her voice isn't steady and her vibrato is weird. Way too fast or something.

CLAY all the way!!

And 205!!!

I think Kimberly (the blonde) has total star quality and such power. I can see it coming down between her, Clay, and Ruben.

Well the marine has country voice. Of course he nailed it. I think Carmen sounds pretty good with country songs. Kimberly was good yesterday (her best).

Which one is the guy with high voice? Corey or Ricky? Corey did ok but nowhere as good as his performance during motown week.

Josuha. He went first yesterday.
Julia has some 'attitude', or at least that's how I sense it.

Carmen's voice can be rough at times but then she's young, that can be taught. She does have the voice to begin with.

Clay and Ruben... they're unstoppable. But if Kimberly C dresses like she did yesterday, they better watch out :lol:

I think it is Corey. I like the "Hercules" guy. I haven't really thought much of Corey since the beginning.


What about the last guy to go....you know the red headed guy. What do you think of him?

Do you think that last years crew was better?

Plus, Simon was on pretty good behavior last night. Paula and Randy never have a bad thing to say anymore.

I want criticism!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :P

I can't remember who's the hercules guy. I'm not too fond of Corey who's basically a Justin Guarini clone but Ricky's voice grates on my nerves more. His vibrato is just, I dunno. Plus his annoying smile. He sang well in One Last Cry by Brian McKnight but that's the only performance by him that I enjoy.

Red headed guy? Clay you mean? He's one of the best.

I did not watch it last year, but I know Kelly should 'lose some weight' :) I wonder if Simon asked her to do this last year.

Simon really had nothing to say yesterday because the contestants did okay (or at least better than previous performance like Corey and Julia).